Christmas morning had always followed the same comforting rhythm in our house. Soft music playing, cinnamon rolls baking, wrapping paper covering the living room floor. It was predictable in the best way, familiar and safe. I believed that kind of consistency was happiness.
I was wrong.
My husband Greg and I had been together for twelve years. We weren’t dramatic people. Our life was built on routines that fit together easily: school drop-offs, shared coffee mugs, Sunday breakfasts, quiet evenings that didn’t need distractions. We had one daughter, Lila, who was eleven and still chose to believe in Santa. Not because she was unaware, but because she liked holding onto a little magic. Every year she left cookies and a handwritten note by the tree. That year she wrote, “Thank you for trying so hard.” I cried when I read it.
A week before Christmas, a small package arrived in the mail. It was wrapped in thick, cream-colored paper, elegant and careful, the kind you hesitate to tear. There was no return address. Only Greg’s name written across the top in unfamiliar, graceful handwriting.
I handed it to him without thinking much of it. The moment he saw the name, he froze. His thumb traced the letters as if they burned.
“Callie,” he whispered.
The name hadn’t been spoken in our home for more than a decade.
Callie was his first love. He had mentioned her once early in our relationship, on a night when honesty came easily. They had broken up after college without closure. He told me it had nearly broken him, and that meeting me later showed him what real commitment looked like. That was all I ever knew.
Continue reading on the next page…