Sheriff Dan Mawhorr said initial reports indicate the buggy was traveling lawfully on the right-hand side when the Jeep struck from behind. “Visibility and speed are key factors under review,” he explained, noting the rural stretch is narrow and poorly lit — a common hazard in areas shared by cars and horse-drawn vehicles.
Emergency response involved multiple agencies, including Adams County EMS, Berne and Geneva Police, Berne Fire Department, and Indiana State Police. First responders described the scene as intense, with scattered passengers and debris and the buggy destroyed. The horse did not survive the crash.
Photos released show the buggy’s splintered frame, crushed wheels, and personal belongings strewn across the pavement. The Jeep sustained heavy front-end damage and rested in a roadside ditch.
The crash has deeply impacted Berne’s Amish community, one of the Midwest’s largest Swiss-Amish settlements. Neighbors are organizing support for the Schwartz family, providing meals, transportation, and financial aid. A local elder said, “When tragedy strikes one family, it touches everyone. We take care of our own.”
Accidents involving horse-drawn buggies remain a persistent challenge. Buggies travel at 5–10 mph while modern vehicles often exceed 55 mph, leaving little reaction time — especially at night. Safety advocates urge motorists to slow down, stay alert, and respect reflective markings and slow-moving vehicle signs.
Local officials stress patience and awareness save lives. Sheriff Mawhorr added, “Rural motorists must remain alert and give horse-drawn vehicles extra space. We share the road, and safety is everyone’s responsibility.”
Authorities continue investigating factors such as speed, braking distance, visibility, and possible driver impairment. Toxicology results from Ocilka’s blood draw are pending, and witness interviews are ongoing.
Meanwhile, the Schwartz family receives community support. Local churches have organized prayer gatherings, and donation drives are underway for medical and transportation expenses. Residents emphasize the strength of faith and community during such crises.
This tragic incident highlights the delicate balance between modern vehicles and traditional horse-drawn transportation. For many Amish families, buggies remain essential for daily life — work, worship, and family visits — yet sharing high-speed roads carries real risks.
As the investigation continues, the message from law enforcement and local leaders is clear: stay alert, slow down, and respect all road users. “Tragedies like this aren’t just accidents,” Sheriff Mawhorr said. “They’re preventable.”
If you drive in rural areas, take extra precautions — every second counts when sharing the road with slower vehicles. Stay safe and spread awareness.