The first time Lily said it, I laughed. I thought it was one of those odd, innocent things children say, unaware of the weight of their words. But on the drive home from daycare, traffic crawling, the radio low, she asked with total confidence, “Daddy, can we invite my real dad to dinner on Father’s Day?”
My hands gripped the steering wheel tighter than I realized. I forced a laugh that didn’t reach my chest and asked her to explain. Lily, five years old, swinging her legs in her car seat, told me simply: a man came sometimes when I was at work. He brought chocolate. He sat with Mommy at the table. Sometimes she cooked for him. And he called himself her “real daddy.”
The words hit me like a physical blow. My heart raced. My breath caught. I tried to reason it away: children imagine things. Stories get mixed up. But Lily was never a storyteller. She was precise, observant, and stubbornly honest. That truth pressed against my chest with an almost unbearable weight.
That night, I barely slept. I stared at the ceiling, running every possible scenario through my mind. Confronting my wife without proof could destroy everything we’d built, but staying silent felt wrong. I decided to turn Lily’s words into a game—a careful, controlled experiment.
“What if we invited your real dad to dinner as a surprise? But we don’t tell Mommy. It’ll be our secret,” I said.
Her face lit up instantly. She clapped her hands, thrilled at the idea of a “secret plan.” That joy nearly broke me.
Continue reading on next page…