Allegations in the Filing
The complaint states that federal records and fingerprint comparisons indicate Bien-Aime is the same individual previously identified under another name and subject to a removal order. Authorities allege that the earlier case involved entry into the United States using fraudulent travel documents, followed by an order of removal that was not carried out.
Prosecutors further claim that the individual later remained in the U.S., adopted a new identity, and applied for legal status under that name. The filing also alleges that permanent residency was obtained through misrepresentation related to marital status. The government contends that certain documents submitted in support of those applications were not valid.
The DOJ says the matter came to light through fingerprint analysis and data reviews conducted as part of a broader initiative by federal agencies to identify potential fraud in the naturalization process.
Response From the Former Mayor
Bien-Aime, who was elected mayor of North Miami in 2019 and later ran unsuccessfully for county office, declined to comment when contacted by reporters. His attorney said they are reviewing the filing and plan to respond through the legal process, adding that no further public comment will be made while the case is pending.
Possible Legal Implications
If the government succeeds in court, the case could have legal and political implications related to Bien-Aime’s previous public office. Local election rules require candidates to be U.S. citizens and registered voters. Officials emphasized that the civil complaint is an allegation and that the matter will be decided by the court.
The case remains ongoing, and no final determination has been made.
The Justice Department filed a civil complaint to revoke the U.S. citizenship of former North Miami mayor, Philippe Bien-Aime, alleging he fraudulently obtained naturalization by concealing material facts about his past. The case underscores that U.S. citizenship is a… pic.twitter.com/YZrSc0EMOR
— US Attorney Reding Quiñones (@USAO_SDFL) February 20, 2026