“Puppies aren’t stuffed animals,” Newkirk said. “It’s disheartening that Kim missed the opportunity to support shelter dogs and instead reinforced the idea that animals can be luxury gifts. The criticism she received online is completely valid.”
Newkirk also referenced Kardashian’s sister, Khloé Kardashian, who reportedly gave her children a dog for Christmas as well. She encouraged the family to consider adoption, volunteering at shelters, sponsoring adoption events, or funding spay-and-neuter programs—actions that could make a tangible impact on homeless animals.
Despite the backlash, Kim has yet to publicly respond. The controversy follows a string of glamorous holiday highlights, including a striking Instagram post of herself in Thierry Mugler’s vintage 1986 silver corset dress, styled with bold earrings, sleek high ponytail, and brown-toned makeup, posing in front of a decorated Christmas tree with her children—North, Saint, Chicago, and Psalm.
The incident has reignited broader conversations about responsible pet ownership, celebrity influence, and the ethics of gifting animals, especially during the festive season. Experts remind fans and parents alike that pets are lifelong commitments requiring care, attention, and love—not just holiday showpieces.
What do you think about giving pets as gifts? Share your thoughts and join the conversation on responsible animal care this holiday season!